The Cell Theory and Where It Falls Short
Quick answer How a set of scattered observations under early microscopes hardened into the cell theory, and the four honest exceptions every student should be able to name.
In 1665 Robert Hooke cut a wafer-thin slice of cork, put it under a microscope he had built himself, and saw a honeycomb of tiny empty boxes. He called them cells. What he was actually looking at were only the dead walls left behind after the living contents had disappeared, so the first cell anyone ever saw was not alive. A few years later Anton van Leeuwenhoek, using better lenses, became the first person to see and describe a living cell. For nearly two centuries these stayed as observations and nothing more.
The theory came in two steps. Matthias Schleiden, a botanist, examined a very large number of plants and concluded that all plants are made of cells. Theodore Schwann, a zoologist, studied animal tissues, noticed that animal cells are bounded by a thin outer layer instead of a wall, and proposed that the bodies of animals and plants are made of cells and the products of cells. Put together, this became the statement that all living organisms are composed of cells and products of cells. But neither man could explain where a brand new cell comes from. That gap was filled by Rudolf Virchow, who argued that every cell arises from a pre-existing cell by division, summed up in the Latin phrase Omnis cellula-e cellula. So the modern cell theory has three parts: all organisms are made of one or more cells, the cell is the basic structural and functional unit of life, and all cells come from pre-existing cells.
Now the exceptions, because the theory is a very good generalisation and not a law. First, viruses are not made of cells at all. A virus is a nucleic acid inside a protein coat with no protoplasm and no machinery of its own, and it can multiply only inside a living host cell. Viroids, which are just naked RNA, and prions, which are infectious proteins, are even further from being cells. Second, some organisms are coenocytic, meaning a single continuous mass of cytoplasm holds many nuclei with no cross walls dividing it into separate cells. Rhizopus, a common bread mould, and the alga Vaucheria are the usual examples, and in them the tidy idea of one cell with one nucleus simply does not apply. Third, the very first cell on earth could not have arisen from a pre-existing cell, so the third part of the theory cannot cover the origin of life itself. Fourth, mature mammalian red blood cells and the mature sieve tube elements of the phloem throw out their nucleus and yet continue to work as living parts of the body.
Cells also vary enormously in size and shape. Mycoplasma, the smallest cells known, are only about three-tenths of a micrometre long, while typical bacteria are three to five micrometres. A human red blood cell is about seven micrometres across, nerve cells are among the longest cells in the body, and the largest isolated single cell is the egg of an ostrich. Shape follows the job: red blood cells are biconcave discs so gases diffuse in and out quickly, columnar epithelial cells of the gut are tall and packed side by side for absorption, and a nerve cell is drawn out into a long thread because its job is to carry a signal from one place to a distant one.
- Hooke saw dead cork cells in 1665; Leeuwenhoek was the first to see and describe a living cell
- Schleiden worked on plants, Schwann on animals, and Virchow added that every cell comes from a pre-existing cell
- Viruses, viroids and prions are not cells, so they sit outside the cell theory altogether
- Coenocytic organisms such as Rhizopus and Vaucheria have many nuclei in one continuous mass of cytoplasm
- Mature mammalian red blood cells and mature sieve tube elements are living but have no nucleus
- Mycoplasma is the smallest cell at about 0.3 micrometre; the largest isolated single cell is the ostrich egg
