What Does It Mean to Be Alive?
Quick answer Biology opens with a test that sounds easy and turns out to be hard: separating the living from the non-living. The usual answers only half work.
If someone hands you a mango sapling and a plastic model of a mango sapling, you can tell them apart in a second. But if you are asked to write down the rule you used, the job suddenly gets difficult. Every property people usually suggest turns out to fit some non-living things too, or to leave out some living things. That is exactly why this chapter starts by testing each property carefully instead of simply listing them.
The properties normally put forward are growth, reproduction, metabolism, cellular organisation, ability to sense and respond to the surroundings, self-replication, self-regulation and interaction. All of these are genuinely seen in living things, so all of them are characteristics of life. The sharper question is which of them are defining.
A property is defining only if it passes two tests at once. First, it must be present in every living organism, with no exceptions. Second, it must be absent from every non-living object. A property that fails either test may still be useful for describing life, but it cannot be used as a definition. Keep this two-part test in your head and use it to justify your answers instead of reciting a list.
You will see in the next two sections that growth fails the second test, because non-living objects can also get bigger, and it partly fails the first test as well, because a fully grown adult animal or a dead organism does not grow. Reproduction fails the first test, because plenty of living organisms never reproduce in their whole lifetime. Metabolism, on the other hand, passes both tests. Cellular organisation passes both as well, and the ability to sense and respond to the environment leads us to the idea of consciousness.
One more warning before we start. Being alive is not the same as being able to move about, and it is not the same as being visible. A seed lying in a tin, a bacterium in curd, and a peepal tree in the school ground are all living. A moving toy car and a river that carves out a valley are not. Movement, size and visibility are not part of the test at all.
- Growth, reproduction, metabolism, cellular organisation and the ability to sense and respond are all characteristics of life
- A defining property must be present in every living organism and absent from every non-living object
- Growth and reproduction fail this two-part test, so they are characteristic but not defining
- Metabolism and cellular organisation pass the test, and consciousness is treated as the defining property of living organisms
- Movement, visibility and size are not part of the test for life at all
