Nitrogenous Wastes and the Three Excretory Patterns
Quick answer Ammonia is cheap to make but needs a flood of water to remove; uric acid is expensive to make but needs almost none. Where an animal sits between these two extremes is decided by how much water it can spare.
Living cells are chemical factories that never shut down, and every factory produces waste. Carbohydrates and fats burn cleanly enough, leaving carbon dioxide and water behind. Proteins and nucleic acids are different, because they carry nitrogen. When an amino acid is broken down for energy, the amino group is stripped off first, and that nitrogen leaves the cell as ammonia (NH3). Ammonia is the cheapest nitrogenous waste an animal can produce, because the cell spends nothing extra to make it. It is also by far the most toxic. Even a small rise in the ammonia level of body fluids interferes with the nervous system, so an animal that excretes ammonia must get rid of it the moment it is formed, and washing it out takes a great deal of water. Ammonia is very soluble, so a large volume of water can carry it away easily; but a land animal simply does not have that much water to throw away.
This one trade-off, the cost of making the waste against the water needed to remove it, is what produces the three excretory patterns you have to know. The first is ammonotelism, the direct excretion of ammonia. Many bony fishes, aquatic amphibians and aquatic insects are ammonotelic. In these animals ammonia is not really a job for the kidney at all: because it is so soluble and diffuses so readily, most of it leaves straight across the general body surface or across the gill surfaces, usually in the form of ammonium ions. The animal is surrounded by fresh water, so the water bill is effectively zero, and it saves the energy that other animals spend on converting ammonia into something safer.
The second pattern is ureotelism. Mammals, many terrestrial amphibians and marine fishes are ureotelic. Here the ammonia produced by cellular metabolism is converted into urea, and in humans that conversion happens in the liver. This is the point students most often get wrong: the liver makes the urea, the kidney only removes it. Urea is released from the liver into the blood, travels to the kidneys, and is filtered out there. Because urea is far less toxic than ammonia, the blood can carry it safely and the body does not have to excrete it instantly, which means a moderate amount of water is enough. Notice that marine fishes are ureotelic even though they live in water, while the bony fishes listed as ammonotelic are the fresh water ones. The difference is not water in the surroundings but usable water: sea water is saltier than a fish's body fluids, so fresh water is constantly being pulled out of a marine fish across its gills. For it, water is scarce in exactly the way it is scarce for a desert animal, and a shark is the standard example of a ureotelic fish.
The third pattern is uricotelism. Reptiles, birds, land snails and insects excrete nitrogen mainly as uric acid, in the form of a pellet or a thick paste, with very little loss of water. Uric acid is almost insoluble, so it can be dumped in a semi-solid form. Making it costs the most energy of the three, but for an animal living on dry land, or developing inside a shelled egg where the waste has to be stored harmlessly until hatching, that energy is worth spending.
Excretion is not carried out by kidneys everywhere in the animal kingdom. Simpler animals use simpler structures, and the chapter lists them in order of increasing complexity. Protonephridia or flame cells are found in Platyhelminthes such as flatworms, in rotifers, in some annelids and in the cephalochordate Amphioxus; their main job is osmoregulation, that is, control of water and salt balance, rather than waste removal. Nephridia are the tubular excretory structures of earthworms and other annelids, and they help remove nitrogenous wastes as well as maintain fluid balance. Malpighian tubules in insects such as cockroaches remove nitrogenous wastes and are also responsible for osmoregulation, while antennal glands or green glands do the job in crustaceans like prawns.
- Nitrogen leaves protein and nucleic acid breakdown as ammonia; the animal then either excretes it directly or spends energy converting it into something less toxic.
- Ammonotelic animals (many bony fishes, aquatic amphibians, aquatic insects) lose ammonia mostly by diffusion across the body surface or gill surfaces as ammonium ions.
- Ureotelic animals (mammals, many terrestrial amphibians, marine fishes) convert ammonia into urea in the liver; the kidney only filters that urea out of the blood.
- Uricotelic animals (reptiles, birds, land snails, insects) excrete uric acid as a pellet or paste, which loses almost no water.
- Toxicity falls and the energy cost of manufacture rises in the order ammonia, urea, uric acid; water required for excretion falls in the same order.
- Other excretory structures: protonephridia (flatworms, rotifers, some annelids, Amphioxus), nephridia (earthworm), Malpighian tubules (cockroach), antennal or green glands (prawn).
